Numbers   Charts   Ideas

Marxism, Power and Freedom

ERIC Hoffer writes that when the "scribes" are in, working for the ruling class, they are happy to do its bidding and order the lower orders around.  But when the scribes are out, meaning that the government can't afford them after a societal collapse, then the scribes decide to represent the "people" and enter a phase where they critique the ruling class.

In our day, I suppose, the scribes do both.  Our educated elite critiques the ruling class on behalf of the traditionally marginalized and it also delights in expert-ology, commissioning like-minded experts to boost its social theories and create government programs to implement them.

What the educated want, says Hoffer, is "power, lordship, and opportunities for imposing action."

That is why the educated fell in love with Marxism.  It said: the workers are being horribly exploited by capitalism.  Therefore we should give absolute political power, lordship, and opportunities to run things to the educated elite to liberate the workers from their slavery.

In fact the opposite happened.  Wherever Marxism was tried the workers got oppressed and exploited worse than before.

More ...

Christopher Chantrill Follow chrischantrill on Twitter

Christopher Chantrill is a writer and conservative, and author of Road to the Middle Class. He runs usgovernmentspending.com, the go-to resource for government finance data, is a frequent contributor to the American Thinker, and blogs regularly at Rare.us. He lives in Seattle, Washington ...

 
 
Books
Road to the Middle Class shows how people change their culture from country to city. Price: $0.99 at Amazon.
Latest review of US government finances from the folks at usgovernment-spending.com. Price: $0.99 at Amazon.
Free download of the latest draft of An American Manifesto, a vision of the good society after the end of liberalism.
 
Media Content

American Thinker

Weekly opeds starting in late 2003.

Rare.us

Blogging starting in October 2013.

 
Sites

Government Spending

Numbers, charts, analysis of government spending in the US. You can make your own spending charts and download spending data.

Government Revenue

Numbers, charts, analysis of government revenue in the US. You can make your own revenue charts and download tax data.

Government Debt

Numbers, charts, analysis of government debt in the US. You can make your own charts of debt over the years and download data.

Federal Budget

Numbers, charts, analysis of the US federal budget. You can create your own custom charts, and look at budget projections and compare estimated with actual.

Spending 101

Take a course in government spending. It’s free!

US President Elections

Results of United States presidential elections.

US Midterm Elections

Results of United States House and Senate midterm elections.

UK Public Spending

Numbers, charts, analysis of public spending in the UK. You can make your own spending charts and download spending data.

Middle Class

Blog and book. People get into the middle class with the cultural capital of religion, mutual aid, education, and law.

American Manifesto

Blog and book. What should America be like in the life after liberalism when civil society replaces the administrative welfare state?

Stuck on Stupid

Blog and book. What went wrong in the nightmare of the Great Depression when, for ten long years, American was stuck on stupid?

US Bailout

First there was TARP at $700 billion and change. But did you know that the total financial bailout of 2008, in spending and guarantees, amounted to over $20 trillion?

Contact